A Fairer Way to Pay for Public Safety
Joe McKenney | Great Falls City Commissioner
Your Voice, for a Thriving Great Falls.
Great Falls is facing a serious public safety funding crisis. We need to find new ways to support our police and fire departments without continuing to place so much of the burden on homeowners and businesses.
I've been working on an idea that could help.
Great Falls is fortunate to have nonprofit organizations that provide medical care, help families, support our neighbors and contribute to our community in countless ways.
But here's something many people may not know.
Property taxes help pay for police and fire protection. Homeowners and businesses contribute through those taxes, but many privately owned nonprofit properties, including qualifying hospitals, churches and charitable organizations, are exempt.
These properties still benefit from police and fire protection without contributing to those services through property taxes.
I suspect many nonprofit property owners haven't given this much thought. Most people aren't familiar with the details of local government funding. Why would they be?
Nonprofits do pay for electricity, natural gas, water, sewer and sanitation. Those services aren't free. So why should police and fire protection be any different?
What I'm Proposing
I'd like the Montana Legislature to consider giving cities the option of establishing a fair, reasonable and enforceable Public Safety Services Fee, Assessment, or Other Funding Mechanism for qualifying privately owned, tax-exempt properties.
Here's what I have in mind:
Keep existing property tax exemptions. This would be a separate way to help fund public safety, not a change to nonprofit property tax exemptions.
Include both police and fire protection. Money collected would be dedicated to those services.
Establish reasonable contributions. Property size, use and service needs could be considered. Not every property would necessarily pay the same amount.
Show taxpayers where the money goes. Communities should know how much is collected and how it's spent.
Other states have explored similar approaches. West Virginia law allows municipalities to establish fees for police and fire protection. Wisconsin permits certain fire protection fees, and Pennsylvania has provisions for some fire protection assessments.
Montana would need legislation written specifically for our laws. We'd need to work through which properties would qualify, how amounts would be determined and how the funding would be collected.
100% Local Control
One thing I want to make clear.
I'm not proposing another state mandate. The Legislature would simply give Montana cities the authority to consider this funding option.
Each community would decide for itself whether to establish a program, based on its own circumstances and public safety needs.
I haven't proposed a specific rate. That would require further research and discussion. Businesses, homeowners and nonprofits all contribute to our community in different ways. We all provide a public benefit. The question is how we can more fairly share the cost of police and fire protection that benefits everyone.
I'd particularly like to hear from nonprofit leaders. They understand their organizations and the financial responsibilities they already carry. I want to hear their ideas and concerns.
Could this be an opportunity to work together on a fair public safety funding solution?
Joe McKenney | Great Falls City Commissioner
Your Voice, for a Thriving Great Falls.
Personal proposal for public discussion. Not an official position of the Great Falls City Commission.